De Anima

Aristotle · edition credit: Edwin Wallace

Book 2, reading section 9

Open in workspace
Contents of this edition

Smell and its object are less easy to determine than the other senses which we have discussed: we do not see, in fact, what is the specific character of smell so clearly as we do that of sound or colour.

The reason of this is that this sense is not developed in us to nearly the same degree of delicacy as it is in other animals.

Man*s sense of smell is really poor: he never perceives the scent of anything odoriferous unless when it is accompanied by either pleasure or pain — a fact which seems to point to a want of delicate exactness in the organ.

It is, we may suppose, with similar limitations that hard-eyed animals perceive colours: we may imagine, that is, that they become conscious of the different kinds of colours only in so far as they create fear or its opposite: and it is in a correspondingly indirect fashion that men perceive smells.

And thus, while the sense of smell is analogous to the sense of taste, and the specific kinds of flavour resemble the different sorts of odour, we possess the sense of taste in a condition of greater perfection, because taste is itself a species of the sense of touch: and in man the sense of touch reaches the greatest sensibility.

As regards the other senses, man falls short of many animals: in touch he far surpasses them in the delicacy of his perceptions.

Hence also man is the most intelligent of animals.

A proof of this is that, within the human species, men are of good or bad natural parts in virtue of this very organ of sense and of no one other sense: the hard-fleshed being dull of understanding, while the soft-fleshed are gifted with good natural ability.

Smells are like flavours, one sweet, another bitter.

While however, in some bodies smell and taste correspond, both for example being sweet, in others they are opposed to one another.

There are also smells which are pungent, and harsh, and sharp, and oily.

But as we have said, because smells are not so clearly distinguishable as flavours, they have received their names from these latter in virtue of the similarity in the things.

Thus the smell of saffron and the smell of honey are alike called sweet, that of thyme and such-like objects is called pungent, and so similarly in other cases.

[There is a further point of resemblance on the part of smell.]

Just as hearing perceives at once the audible and the inaudible, vision the visible and the invisible, and so also with each one of the other senses; smell similarly perceives at once the odorous and the inodorous, whether, as is the case also with what is tasteless, the object be inodorous because it is utterly impossible that it should have a smell, or simply because it has a faint and bad smell.

Like the other senses, smell also forms its perceptions through some intervening medium, as for example, air and water: for water-animals as well as land are held to have the sense of smell.

This also is the case with blood-possessing and bloodless animals, and further with those which fly in air, many of them being brought from a great distance to their food after having smelled it.

And hence in fact it appears to be a disputed question whether all animals smell in the same manner.

Man only perceives a smell while inhaling the breath: when not inhaling but breathing it forth or checking it, he has no sense of smell, no matter whether the object be far away or close at hand, nor even if it should be placed on the inside of the nostril.

And it is indeed a fact common to all animals that an object placed actually on the organ itself is not perceived: but the inability to perceive an odour without inhaling breath is a trait peculiar to man, as will in fact be found on trial.

And thus, we might conclude, bloodless animals as not inhaling breath must have some other sense beyond those we have mentioned.

This, however, is impossible, so far as they actually have a sense of smell; and their perception of what is pleasant or disagreeable is the sense of smell.

And further, such animals are found to be destroyed by the same violent odours as destroy men, such as asphalt and brimstone, and the like; so that (it follows) these bloodless animals must also have the sense of smell, although it be without inhaling breath.

There seems at the same time to be a difference bet^\'een this organ as possessed by man and as possessed by other animals, similar to that between the visual organs of men and those of hard-eyed animals.

The former have a protection and, as it were, an envelope in the eyelids, which must be moved and drawn apart in order to enable the animal to see, whereas hard-eyed animals have nothing of this kind but see at once what happens in the medium* of the pellucid.

Similarly the organ of smell is, in the case of some animals, uncovered just as is the eye, while, in the case of those inhaling air, it has a covering which is opened out on drawing breath, by the dilatation of the veins and pores.

Hence animals that inhale air cannot perceive a smell in water, because in order to smell they must inhale and this is impossible in water.

Smell, it should be added, is of what is dry, just as taste is of what is liquid, and the organ of the sense of smell is potentially of such a nature.